Jazz reviewer pulls glowing review of my album so as to ‘stand with Israel’

Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr

Some disturbing news: A very complimentary review of my new CD [The Way to Peace] has been pulled because of politics. The reviewer’s name is Brent Black, his website is criticaljazz.com….

Here’s what he posted on Facebook about his decision to pull the review (in lower case as he wrote it):

“my humble apologies to my jewish friends for reviewing rich sigel (sic) an anti-zionist peace activist that supports the destruction of israel. had i know (sic) who he was and what he was all about i never would have given him 30 seconds of my time. his review is pulled and e mail blocked. again my apologies i stand with israel NEVER against her but firmly against her enemies.”

The claim that I support the destruction of Israel is pure libel. I have never made any statements advocating the destruction of Israel, or the destruction of anyone or anything. The irony here is that in his review Black makes it a point to separate his disagreement with my politics from his assessment of the music I have brought to the world with this new recording. (Read review below.) He has obviously flushed that integrity down the toilet with his libelous announcement and decision to pull the review. 

The original review:

Rich Siegel  “The Way to Peace”

By Brent Black, Critical Jazz (March 23, 2012)

Perhaps the greatest joy in writing about music and predominately jazz in particular would have to be taking the occasional sonic path less traveled. Had someone told me two years ago I would have been reviewing the work of an anti-Zionist peace activist, a request that this individual be drug tested would be the expected response from those few that travel in my inner circle.

The Way To Peace is not a political manifesto in the strictest sense of the
word but instead I will allow Siegel’s words to speak for him:

³I sought a marriage of spirituality and peace activism, combining my
originals with some extraordinary cover material, notably by New York
composer Kirk Nurock and Lebanese composer Ahmad Kaabour, as well as others.²

From a purely musical perspective, Siegel is a gifted instrumentalist with
rich vocals that glide effortlessly along with his playing.
http://www.criticaljazz.com/ is actually an outgrowth from some inspiration found in of all places – facebook. Having rather outspoken and often (not always) conservative views on the subject of the Palestinian state, I am long on record as encouraging artists to stay away from such incendiary topics as faith, politics and sexual orientation when it comes to social media. The reasoning for an artist to stay away from such potentially  damaging topics is not to squash an opposing point of view or monopolize a public forum but from a practical standpoint of alienating a large segment of one’s audience.

The one piece of advice given to me by a former editor of separating the
individual from the artist probably best rings true from this perspective.
Rich Siegel is and what he sings about. For this reason alone, The Way To Peace is a stellar recording.

If an artist is to give of them self in a form of expression be it music,
painting or sculpture then all you can ask for is an honest shared
perspective. You can respect an opinion and disagree with it. To
oversimplify Siegel’s music as that of the “peace movement” would be
disingenuous at best. Instead Siegel presents us with an eloquently stated, musically pristine offering of himself and shares a piece of what is in his heart.

Isn’t that what art is all about?


Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments


Sue the a-hole for libel.

Good luck with the album, Rich!

Rich, I read your defense of Atzmon a couple of weeks back (Permission to examine “Jewishness”) and I agree with what you had said, esp relating to Abunimah. Is is possible that libel from Brent black may be b/c of Atzmon?

And with a song like ‘In Palestine’ how did Brent Black not realize what your album was about? I suppose someone is leaning on him hard.

This example is one reason why I support boycotts of everything Israeli and boycotts of Israel’s supporters in social arenas outside of politics I wouldn’t normally favor boycotting. As long they do things like this then boycotting them in every area, musical, educational, literary is fair.

The pettiness and small-minded of these people is astounding. Completely unable to think the situation through, instead coming out with wildly exaggerated hysteria, smearing and unwillingness to engage in thought or debate. Are they trying to portray Jewishness as being synonymous with closed mind bigotry? Because if not they are doing a very good job of it.