Opinion

Oren’s memoir reveals Israel’s elite is hyper-sensitive to U.S. criticism

Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr

Michael Oren’s new book about his years as Israel’s ambassador to the United States will — accidentally for him — turn out to be a big boost to the nonviolent movement for justice in Israel/Palestine. I have read every word, and I hope it reaches the best-seller lists and stays there, as an inadvertent but accurate account of  how Israel’s power elite truly thinks and acts. The book is an extraordinarily revealing look into the highest echelons of the Israeli government, and Oren’s own animosities have prompted him to tell more than he may have intended.

The book is called Ally, and subtitled My Journey Across the American-Israeli Divide. A better subtitle would be How Israel’s Government Disrespects Americans, Particularly American Jews, But Is Still Ultra-Sensitive to Criticism.

First reports have already jumped on a couple of Oren’s more ludicrous assertions, such as that President Obama is too soft on “Muslims” because his two Muslim fathers abandoned him, and that American Jewish journalists are too hard on Israel because they are afraid of anti-Semitism if they don’t criticize it. But there are plenty more juicy cherries to be picked from this particular tree.

Let’s start with Oren’s clash with the late Bob Simon, the CBS reporter who stood out as genuine and honest amid the timid mediocrity of most television journalism. Simon, who died too young in a car crash earlier this year, is right at the top of Oren’s long enemies list.

Bob Simon
Bob Simon

Here’s what enraged Oren: Simon, an experienced, courageous newsman who had been captured by the Iraqis during the first Gulf War, started working on a 60 Minutes segment about how Christians were suffering under the long Israeli occupation of the West Bank. Oren went into action immediately, going straight to Jeffrey Fager, the chairman of CBS News. Oren writes, “Fager rebuffed any charges of bias, pointing out that the program [60 Minutes] had positively profiled the Israeli Air Force and Hadassah Hospital.” Right away, this is an interesting revelation, confirming the suspicions of many media-watchers that the mainstream U.S. press regularly does puff-pieces about Israel to ward off criticism.

But Bob Simon kept after the story. He interviewed Oren himself, which turned out to be a painful experience for the ambassador: “A veteran now of hundreds of interviews, many of them hostile, I was shocked by Simon’s venom.” Simon even had the temerity to ask Oren directly why Israel was trying to suppress the story. Oren is predictably outraged at the segment that finally is aired. He notes that Simon is Jewish, which seems to increase his animosity.

Oren’s efforts to muzzle the broadcast were not entirely unsuccessful. He revealed that part of his strategy had been to delay the broadcast until after the football season, when 60 Minutes, which follows the games on Sundays, would have a smaller audience. Simon’s report did not air until April 22, 2012.

The Bob Simon episode is just one example of two major themes in this memoir; Oren’s (and Israel’s) acute sensitivity to any criticism whatsoever, and his rage at American Jews who do not follow the party line. Oren got his marching orders from Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu right from the start:

“I have three words of advice for you,” Netanyahu told me in one of our first meetings. “Media. Media. Media.”

And so Israel’s top leader, who is supposed to be preoccupied with his nation’s survival, seems to constantly be calling Oren by cellphone with unimportant PR demands. Oren stumbles with writer’s block on his op-ed articles and letters to the editor. “Netanyahu, his impatience oozing from the phone, upbraided me, ‘Suck it up and get writing.'” The prime minister is also not satisfied with Oren’s TV presence: “Netanyahu judged my initial television appearances as ‘bloodless.’ He was right.'”

In time, Oren gets better at the PR game. As the religious ultra-right in Israel grows, there are reports that “ultra-Orthodox men spat at female Israelis outside of Jerusalem.” An anonymous Obama administration official warned that Israel was becoming another theocratic Iran. Oren remembers, “Though off the record, the remark so incensed Netanyahu that he instructed me to phone congressional leaders and remind them that women have served as the chief justice of Israel’s Supreme Court, the Speaker of the Knesset, and the prime minister.”

Please Make a Tax-Deductible Donation to Mondoweiss Today

Another time, Oren gets an urgent call from the prime minister’s office, ordering him to get to a secure diplomatic phone immediately. He interrupts his Thanksgiving, sprinting through the Macy’s parade to reach the Israeli consulate on the east side of Manhattan, to learn what the top secret big crisis is: the Palestinian Authority is applying for state status in the United Nations General Assembly. Oren is ordered to start calling U.S. Congressmen immediately to block the move. He heads back to Washington, and at 4 a.m. he and Netanyahu discuss the looming danger.

In this never-ending PR campaign, Oren complains he is regularly stabbed in the back by Bob Simon and many other American Jews. Our next installment will look more closely at his hostility and barely concealed contempt for them.

138 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Oren admits of the presence of the large number of Jews in the media.But he thinks that they are not doing their job.They are antisemitic.They write negative and they separate themselves from settler,IDF,from Rabbi. It seems he wants them to support Israel and identify themselves with rabbi,settlers,and IDF He complains since he believes that the Jewish journalist have power to modify the attitude of the audience .but they are not doing it.That is his concern.… Read more »

Keep it coming and thank you, James! I, for one, am thrilled that you feel that this “book is an extraordinarily revealing look into the highest echelons of the Israeli government, and Oren’s own animosities have prompted him to tell more than he may have intended.” It’s about time for all the dirty laundry to be aired and secrets to be dumped. The world needs to see the full unmasking. Funnily enough, someone mentioned “invisibility… Read more »

RE: “The Bob Simon episode is just one example of two major themes in this memoir; Oren’s (and Israel’s) acute sensitivity to any criticism whatsoever, and his rage at American Jews who do not follow the party line.” ~ North FROM WIKIPEDIA (Narcissistic supply): [EXCERPT] Narcissistic supply is a concept introduced into psychoanalytic theory by Otto Fenichel in 1938, to describe a type of admiration, interpersonal support or sustenance drawn by an individual from his… Read more »

Just read the most pathetic thing ever from Josh Marshall at TPM. Mr. Marshall has been following the Oren ibroglio, and the Israeli election. And in this article “The Ridiculous Mr. Oren” Josh Marshall explains his deeply thought out support for the two-state solution and Zionism: “I believe all people deserve this but especially with the Palestinian people because, much as each side expresses the bond through bloodshed and hate, I believe the Jewish and… Read more »

Oren went into action immediately, going straight to Jeffrey Fager, the chairman of CBS News. … he [Netanyahu] instructed me to phone congressional leaders and remind them…. Oren is ordered to start calling U.S. Congressmen immediately to block the move. …

What I see is an unbelievable amount privilege and access wasted on petulant idiocy and temper tantrums.

Great analysis, James. I haven’t read the book, but I know some of its main characters.