Theodor Herzl wasn’t Jewish, according to Israeli minister

Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr

The latest news from the one and only Jewish state: Israel’s minister of religious services says that Reform Jews are not Jews. The report is from Isabel Kershner of the New York Times:

“The moment a Reform Jew stops following the religion of Israel, let’s say there’s a problem,” the minister, David Azoulay of the Shas party, said on Army Radio, adding, “I cannot allow myself to call such a person a Jew.”

Kershner notes that the Israeli president also has said he doesn’t believe that Reform Jews are Jews:

President Reuven Rivlin infuriated American Reform Jews with remarks he made in the 1980s, when he was a member of the Israeli Parliament. After attending a service at a Reform synagogue in New Jersey, he told an Israeli newspaper, “This is idol worship and not Judaism.”

So what about Theodor Herzl? He was the founder of political Zionism, beginning with his 1896 book The Jewish State. He died in 1904, but his portrait rose above the declaration of Israel’s establishment in 1948, as the picture shows.

Herzl and Ben Gurion, 1948
Herzl and Ben Gurion, 1948

In 1895, he was asked by a journalist, “What is your relation to the Bible?”

“I am a freethinker, and our principle will be: Let everyone seek salvation in his own way.”

The Jewish journalist who posed the question said, “You must be the martyr to this idea [of Zionism]. The orthodox Jews will join you but consider you a bad Jew.”

Actually not a bad Jew: not a Jew at all.

Herzl celebrated Christmas. December 24, 1895:

I was just lighting the Christmas tree for my children when [head Vienna rabbi Moritz] Gudemann arrived. He seemed upset by the “Christian” custom. Well, I will not let myself be pressured! But I don’t mind if they call it the Hannukah tree–or the winter solstice.

More of his freethinking in his Diaries, 1895:

Shall we… end up having a theocracy? No! Faith unites us, science makes us free. Therefore we shall permit no theocratic velleities [inclinations] on the part of our clergy to arise. We shall know how to restrict them to their temples, just as we shall restrict our professional soldiers to their barracks.

Herzl’s disbelief in religion fostered one of his most important political ideas: “my plan to extraterritorialize the holy places [in Jerusalem], to make them res sacrae commercium gentium [holy places above the trafficking of the nations]. That would be a great symbol… La Gerusalemme liberata.”

The Israeli government today honors none of these secular principles, of separation of church and state.

How long before Israel tightens up the Law of Return? Jews will have to chant their haftorah before Israel lets them immigrate, and prove that they have been attending an Orthodox shul.

And David Ben-Gurion in the picture above, Israel’s first Prime Minister. He was a religious person, but something of a theist, according to Wikipedia; he was not devout; some even classify him as an atheist.

Please consider making a tax-deductible donation to Mondoweiss today.
Please consider making a tax-deductible donation to Mondoweiss today.




Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Will Israel continue to accept financial donations from Reform Jews? Should all non-Orthodox members of AIPAC “convert” to Orthodox Judaism just to be safe? 70% of the world’s Jewish population just wants to know how to deal with the one country in the democratic world where liberal Judaism faces the… Read more »

Haha. Did Herzl come from the womb of a Jewish mother? Did he proclaim his conversion to a religion other than Judaism?

“Did he proclaim his conversion to a religion other than Judaism? “

Oh boy, are you missing the point! Citizen,!
When Hophmi (or any of the herd of ilk) start screaming about who is or isn’t Jewish, do they ask me, or Phil or anybody else if we have converted?

Edwin Montagu, a Jewish member of the British Government at the time of the Balfour Declaration, said: “I have always understood, by the Jews before Zionism was invented, that to bring the Jews back to form a nation in the country from which they were dispersed would require Divine leadership.… Read more »

I have never heard a justification for Jewish nationalism that was NOT predicated on some aspect of Jewish supremacy, be it religious, ethnic, racial, economic or military.