Testifying before the City University of New York’s Task Force on Anti-Semitism

Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr

In late February, the City University of New York (CUNY) announced it was launching a Task Force on anti-Semitism on campus. This move followed lobbying by the Zionist Organization of America (ZOA), a right-wing group that supports West Bank settlements, which sent a letter to the CUNY chancellor complaining about anti-Semitism and demanding that CUNY “publicly condemn the SJP and its hateful, divisive and anti-Semitic actions” and “hold this group accountable for violation of CUNY rules and policies.” The following post was written by Sarah Schulman, who serves as the faculty advisor the Students for Justice in Palestine chapter at the College of Staten Island, about her experience testifying before the CUNY Task Force and originally appeared on Facebook.

Today I testified before the CUNY Task Force on Anti-Semitism

I was accompanied by my attorney, Jed Eisenstein, president of the board of Jewish Voice for Peace. I also had legal support from Palestine Legal and The Center for Constitutional Rights.

One member of the Task Force, Paul Shechtman, was not present. He is an attorney who- in addition to being on this Task Force- represents the NYPD office who killed Akai Gurley, and his firm has also represented Dominique Strauss-Kahn. In his absence I was interviewed by Judge Barbara Jones.

Upon arrival at their Park Avenue Office, I was presented with a 14 page list of accusations filed by Zionists Organization of America (ZOA), once a mainstream Jewish Organization, it is now a small extremist right-wing group. Even though ZOA has been running a press campaign calling me “Anti-Semitic” in the New York Post and Daily News, actually I was not named anywhere in their letter.

Instead they went after the student group to which I am the faculty advisor, Students for Justice in Palestine at the College of Staten Island. We systematically went through all of the accusations, ALL of which were fabricated or absurd. For example, SJP was accused of drawing swastikas on the walls of our college. However there is no record of such an incident ever taking place. There is no incident report of anyone ever doing such a thing at CSI, even the president of the college does not recall this ever happening.

The letter was really a list of slanders against Muslim students. Over and over there were vague charges that “a Muslim student” said something unpleasant to a Jewish student. But never was there any evidence that this composite Muslim student had anything to do with SJP. These students were never identified, and there were no details like dates.

I also spoke about the students themselves: how much I respect our students, and how much I have been enriched by working with them. How many of our SJP students are Palestinian. Their families have been displaced. Their relatives have been held in illegal detention. They have been denied entry to Israel/Palestine because of their political activism. I told the Task Force that I have come to know the students, and some of their family members. That they have NEVER been anti-semitic or homophobic or done anything that justified any kind of negative institutional response.
One of the accusations was that a “Jewish student” hid her Star of David when she saw Muslim students. Besides the fact that this has nothing to do with SJP, I explained to the Task Force that there are Jews who have dehumanizing views of Arabs, Muslims and Palestinians, and project enormous anxiety onto to them. But that this has nothing to do with Muslim students, themselves. And certainly is not their fault.

Then we discussed the relationship between Zionism and Judaism. I testified that since the onset of Zionism, since Theodore Herzl published his book The Jewish State in 1896, there has been disagreement among Jews regarding Zionism. That for its entire history, for 5,700 years, Judaism has been a dialogic religion rooted in commentary and inquiry. And that this current moment is the only time that Jews have been told to be homogenous in thought. That in fact, this impulse to force all Jews into one opinion is ahistorical and not Judaic.

Finally we got to the question of the inquiry itself. I detailed for the Task Force how the Zionists of America have been harassing me on twitter, sending 10-40 tweets a day to my publisher, reviewers, friends and colleagues calling me a “Terrorist”, how they sabotaged my Wikipedia page inserting a false claim that I went to Gaza as a “guest of Hamas” (I have never been to Gaza and I have no contact with Hamas) and that they have been using the media to harass me because we hold different values.

I then raised the troubling question of Abe Foxman (head of the right-wing Anti-Defamation League) being quoted in the Daily News saying that he approved of how CUNY was handling me. “How does Abe Foxman even know HOW CUNY is handling me?” I asked. “How does a group of bullies who are not even reputable, get to file a list of absurd accusations and get CUNY to go to the trouble and expense of creating a task force?” And I said that I see an “inappropriate relationship between ZOA and CUNY.” Finally I asked, “Why are we even here?”

At the end of the meeting I was asked what I thought The Task Force should include in their final report. My suggestion: “That Students for Justice in Palestine should be treated like every other student group.”

We shall see.

Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Bravo Sarah! And thank you. May justice prevail.

Q: What is the CUNY Task Force’s working definition of antisemitism?

SARAH SCHULMAN- “…Zionists Organization of America (ZOA), once a mainstream Jewish Organization, it is now a small extremist right-wing group.” This “small” group is a member of the Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations. It’s President is Morton Klein who is well known. Yes, it is right-wing and extremist, however, it is part of the combined might of organized Jewry which has become thoroughly Zionist and right-wing. AIPAC is another member of the… Read more »

If the City University of New York was SERIOUS about this problem they would have a task force investigate anti-Zionism on campus. THAT is the real issue. And that would lead to a SERIOUS discussion of the REAL issues involved. Not this money-manufactured crap. The university administrators know this, to their shame.

@ Sarah: That in fact, this impulse to force all Jews into one opinion is ahistorical and not Judaic. I am the classic “non-practicing” Jew. Never got into Judaism. Yet still, to this quote of yours, I must say, amen.