Trending Topics:

U.K. visa denial for Gaza artist is another example of Palestinian culture under attack

Middle East
on 10 Comments

Malak Mattar is 18 years old, and a college student in Istanbul, Turkey. The young artist from Gaza paints mostly haunting portraits that express the pain, persistence, and sumud (resilience) of the Palestinian people, a people who, in the words of the famous Palestinian poet, Mahmoud Darwish, suffer from “an incurable malady, hope.”  

Mattar’s paintings have been shown in exhibitions around the world, from India to Washington DC, but so far, she has not been present at any of these shows outside of Palestine.  Her case made the news last year, when she placed first in Gaza and second in all of the Palestinian territories in the “tawjeehi,” the end of high school exam that is a requirement for Palestinians to attend university.  Her score immediately qualified her for a scholarship in Turkey, which every year offers a full ride package to the top ten Palestinian students. But Mattar’s dreams were shattered when her scholarship went to another young Palestinian, whose greater “qualifications” seemed to be that he was a relative of someone high up in the Palestinian Authority.  Mondoweiss, among a few other progressive outlets, brought enough attention to her case that the scholarship somehow re-materialized.

Painting by Malak Mattar. (Photo: Malak Mattar/Facebook)

Mattar has since been living in Turkey, enrolled in college, and doing what she does so well: paint, and share her people’s stories with the world.

But leaving Gaza has not proven to be the escape to opportunity that she had hoped for.  Just this week, Mattar’s dream of finally being present at one of her world exhibitions were shattered, as she was denied a visa to both France and England.  Her paintings were just shown in Paris and Avignon, and she was looking forward to her first global experience. To top that, her French friends had secured an artist’s studio for a full month for her exclusive use, and she was beyond thrilled at the opportunity to devote herself to painting in this new environment.  But when she went to the French embassy to pick up her passport, she found out she had been denied a visa and, as she wrote, “it looked like nobody had even looked at all the supporting documents I had provided.”

Mattar was still hopeful, as she has also applied for a visa to England, where her paintings, which have already arrived there from France, will be shown this week at the Greenbelt Art festival.  But again, she felt only heartbreak and humiliation, when she had expected elation—her visa application was denied, not be appealed, as the consulate was not convinced she was truly a student, let alone an artist.  

As Mattar wrote in a Facebook post asking her fans to protest the British Consulate’s decision to deny her a visa:  

“I was always told that ‘once you are out of Gaza, you will be free’.
Getting out of Gaza was a dream for me, a dream in which I would be able to study and progress with my art. I have had many of exhibitions in various countries, and in the past I never felt bad for not being able to attend them. Seeing others in Gaza lose their Student Visas and Medicine Travel Permissions, it made me feel more acceptable of not travelling.
Gaza was indeed a cage, but I never thought that the world was just a bigger cage for many people, including myself. 

…….
I had found a refusal letter with a note of not appealing or complaining. which accused me of many things, including the accusation that I was not a real student and that they didn’t believe my intentions. After reading this, I felt compelled to quit making art. This was my first reaction to it. It has really broke my heart. 
I haven’t been able to see my paintings outside Palestine, and I’m afraid I won’t ever be able to.
My dream is to just have the ability to be present with my paintings and attend my exhibition. I really hope this won’t be my Primary dream for so long, but it really feels this way. 
It seems that the hatred of Palestinians, and the ambition to keep us from travelling and living Normal lives, is shared by more than just Israel. However, I will never stop creating Art.”

Mattar’s plight is in keeping with the “lurch to the right” amongst politicians in the West, and the denial of visas to many artists from Global South countries .  Thus Chris Smith, the director of WOMAD international music festival, said that for the first time this year, musicians had rejected invitations rather than face the  “humiliation” of dealing with Britain’s visa application process.  “We’ve had situations where, say, an African artist has been due to come who plays a particularly rare instrument, and we’ll be asked: ‘Can’t you find someone in the UK who plays that instrument?’, which is absurd,” Smith explained. “Culture is being crushed as politicians lurch to the right,” he said, adding “My fear is the situation is only going to get worse.”  

Those of us who advocate cultural boycott are told, ad nauseam, that “art is a bridge across cultures,” which we are somehow trying to cut off.  Yet as the institutional barriers prove ever higher and more selective for some artists, that “bridge” seems to be, like the segregated roads in the West Bank, a bridge that only a select few can cross, regardless of their talents and qualifications.  Malak Mattar will continue painting—art courses through her veins, and its flow cannot be stemmed. Her situation, however, shows the relentless attack on Palestinian culture, and on two-way cultural exchanges. We cannot remain silent, as this assault on global connections escalates.  We can write the British consulate, at [email protected], to protest their denial of a visa for Mattar.  And, until all artists are free to share their gift with the world, we can, and should, boycott complicit artists and institutions, as called for by Palestinian civil society.  

About Nada Elia

Nada Elia is a Palestinian scholar-activist, writer, and grassroots organizer, currently completing a book on Palestinian Diaspora activism.

Other posts by .


Posted In:

10 Responses

  1. just
    just
    August 21, 2018, 12:17 pm

    “Home Office stopped author from speaking at UK festival, says publisher

    Visa refusals mean Palestinian Nayrouz Qarmout unlikely to get to Edinburgh book festival …”

    https://www.theguardian.com/books/2018/aug/12/home-office-stopped-author-nayrouz-qarmout-speaking-uk-festival-edinburgh

    ~~~~~~~~~~

    “Home Office refuses visas for authors invited to Edinburgh book festival

    Festival director Nick Barley says ‘humiliating’ application process will deter writers and damage cultural life in UK …”

    https://www.theguardian.com/books/2018/aug/08/visas-refused-for-a-dozen-authors-invited-to-book-festival

    ~~~~~~~~~

    “Arab arts showcase at Edinburgh fringe beset by visa difficulties

    Nearly a quarter of the performers have had their visas denied more than once and one show has been cancelled completely …”

    https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2017/aug/17/arab-arts-showcase-at-edinburgh-fringe-beset-by-visa-difficulties

  2. pabelmont
    pabelmont
    August 21, 2018, 1:20 pm

    UK Visa system is sick, discriminates against many, without justification, but Labor MPs, who do not discriminate, are accused of antisemitism. Has language any meaning left these days?

    • CigarGod
      CigarGod
      August 21, 2018, 7:12 pm

      Certainly not.
      But it doesn’t matter anyway…since the average person comprehends only 60% of what they read…no matter the language.

  3. JLewisDickerson
    JLewisDickerson
    August 21, 2018, 7:15 pm

    RE: “Malak Mattar will continue painting—art courses through her veins, and its flow cannot be stemmed. Her situation, however, shows the relentless attack on Palestinian culture, and on two-way cultural exchanges.” ~ Nada Elia

    SEE: ■ “The sad, sick racism of Zionism – Brighton’s Anti-War Memorial is defaced” | Posted by Tony Greenstein | Monday, 20 August 2018
    [ 📷 PHOTO]
    • Sussex Friends of Israel ‘prove’ that ‘there is no such thing as Palestine’ by chemically removing all mention of it!
    LINK – http://azvsas.blogspot.com/2018/08/the-sad-sick-racism-of-zionism.html

  4. mondonut
    mondonut
    August 21, 2018, 10:22 pm

    Sure, let’s boycott Israel because some countries do not share your sense of entitlement.

    • Misterioso
      Misterioso
      August 22, 2018, 10:55 am

      @ mondonut

      Sigh. Yet another inane comment from hasbara central.

      Here’s a slice of the ugly truth:

      http://normanfinkelstein.com/2018/08/17/waterless-in-gaza/

      “Waterless in Gaza, August 17, 2018” – Quoted by Dr. Norman Finkelstein:

      EXCERPT:

      “News from veteran journalist, author, and professor Sandy Tolan”

      “Dear Friends, Sandy recently reported from Gaza, sharing stories of loss — but also of resilience. He is on assignment for an investigation into the water crisis in Gaza, where 97 percent of the drinking water wells are unfit for human consumption, and where officials warn of a complete collapse in the water system by 2020. He will be reporting for the Daily Beast, Al Jazeera English, and Public Radio International’s environmental newsmagazine, Living on Earth. Stay tuned here for more on those reports.

      “In the meantime, here are Sandy’s initial dispatches of day-to-day life on the ground in Gaza.
      Follow him on Twitter & Facebook and check out SandyTolan.com for his latest coverage and photos.

      “Sweltering Summer Days by Sandy Tolan
      Photos by Abdel Kareem Hana”

      “On sweltering summer days in Gaza, like today when it hit 95 with 60+ percent humidity, the Shati (Beach) refugee camp can feel unbearable – especially if you don’t have water or electricity.

      “Electricity throughout Gaza runs for four hours a day. A few can afford generators or battery operated fans. But no one drinks the salty water from the tap. Some families spend nearly half of their modest income on drinking water from roaming trucks, pumped to rooftops in dripping hoses. Others, like 19 members of the Nimnim family, can’t afford to buy water at all.”

      • mondonut
        mondonut
        August 22, 2018, 12:06 pm

        @Misterioso

        I think you cut and pasted the wrong boilerplate. Nothing in your comment addresses Visas, supposed restrictions on Palestinian culture, or cultural boycotts.

        But if you are interested in supplying more energy to Gaza you can direct your comments to Hamas and the PLO.

  5. Jackdaw
    Jackdaw
    August 26, 2018, 11:11 am

    Western industrialised countries are very concerned about young, single foreigners coming into their countries on a visa, and than staying there illegally.

    That probably explains why this young lady was denied visas to France and the UK.

    Stop playing the victim all the time.

    • MHughes976
      MHughes976
      August 26, 2018, 3:23 pm

      Yes, as far as I can see the main reasons for visa refusal are, for a student visa, no clear enrolment in a recognised course, and for a general visa, lack of ability to persuade the immi authorities that you fully intend to leave within 6 months. The system must be full of arbitrary decisions. One twist might be that the unpleasant nature of life in Gaza is widely known and this actually increases suspicion that the applicant – who, after all, would like living within a siege perimeter with precarious water and fuel supplies? – will stay to breathe the freer air of Scotland. Your rights become more precarious the more you already suffer wrong.

    • Talkback
      Talkback
      August 26, 2018, 3:27 pm

      Staying there illegaly? Like the founder of your beloved Apartheid Junta who illegaly overstayed in the Ottoman Empire after his visa ran out?

      Not to mention all the Jews who illegaly entered Palestine after 1939.

Leave a Reply