Protest at ZOA Bannon gala shows, Zionism does not unify Jewish community

US Politics
on 4 Comments

Last Sunday, November 12, Mort Klein of the Zionist Organization of America (ZOA) welcomed Steve Bannon to speak at a ZOA “gala,” along with Alan Dershowitz, U.S. Ambassador to Israel David Friedman, ex-Sen. Joe Lieberman (D-CT), and Sen. Tom Cotton (D-AR).

The Times of Israel website reported,

Speaking to the ZOA, Bannon said Trump’s election victory “would not have come without one other person besides Donald Trump — Sheldon Adelson.”

In particular, he said Adelson’s advice helped Trump overcome the release of the “Access Hollywood” tape, in which Trump boasted about sexually assaulting a woman.

“Sheldon Adelson didn’t cut and run,” Bannon said, regarding the time after the scandal broke. “Sheldon Adelson had Donald Trump’s back. Sheldon Adelson offered guidance and counsel and wisdom of how to get through it. He was there for Donald Trump about how to comport oneself and how to dig down deep and it was his guidance and his wisdom that helped get us through it.”

The next day, Adelson issued a statement separating himself from Bannon’s campaign to purge establishment Republicans from the party, and did not attend, although Bannon specifically was at the gala to introduce Adelson, according to the program.

Guests at the ZOA dinner included former White House figures Sebastian Gorka and Sean Spicer.

The ZOA “gala” inside the Grand Hyatt Hotel on E 42nd Street, next to Grand Central Terminal, was matched by protesting Jews outside.                    

The circumstance of IfNotNow and cartoonist Eli Valley protesting in front of the ZOA gala showed a fine Jewish “disunity,” consistent with American Jewish history, where a wide spectrum of identity, from Jewish nationalist to American of the Jewish faith, has always existed, as well as Jews finding that other Jews exhibit Nazi-like behavior.

The unitary peoplehood of Jews is a mirage, as well as the idea that there is a single spokesperson or organization.

The mainstream American Hebrew magazine, in a 1938 editorial, protested Zionist rabbi Stephen S. Wise’s American Jewish Congress campaign to represent American Jews, saying, “As Americans and as Jews we are not willing to give any man or men control over Jewish Affairs.”

The furious editorial called the AJ Congress’ campaign, “the  greatest propaganda drive ever conducted in Jewish life. It has been as unremitting and as carefully planned to deaden all sensibilities as any Hitler propaganda drive ever was.”

In 1948, the American Jewish Committee chairman Jacob Blaustein wrote,  “I am deeply concerned over the concept of the World Jewish Congress that it speak for all Jews everywhere.”

Founded as the Federation of American Zionists in 1896, Zionist Organization of America (ZOA) is an American component of the World Zionist Organization.

Since its beginnings during the 2014 Gaza war, IfNotNow has performed many actions at “mainstream” Jewish organizations, in service of valuing Palestinian lives as dearly as Jewish lives.

In this case, the action was as much for the protection of American Jews as Palestinian Arabs. Eli Valley made a pointed comment on the nexus that is developing with the American alt-Right, Zionists, and the Israeli leadership. (Bannon’s Breitbart news site proudly maintains a news bureau in Israel.) The Forward reported:

He didn’t mince words explaining why he’d given up his Sunday night to protest ZOA.

“I’m here because we need to let the world know that Nazi collaboration is not Judaism, and these motherf—kers should be excommunicated,” he told me.

He was holding a sign that read, “You collaborate with neo-Nazis and call us Kapos?”

“Some of the greatest anti-Semites of our time are Zionists,” Valley said. “That’s no defense.”

IfNotNow, like Open Hillel and Jewish Voice for Peace, attempts to decentralize political Zionism from American Jewish life, while not explicitly disavowing it in all forms.

The J Street organization attempts to bring what one can call a denatured Jewish nationalism to the table, a detoxification of the project, in a quest is to hold on to the Herzlian dream of nationhood.

Vyacheslav von Plehve, Interior Minister in Russia under the Czar.

The drama of ZOA, with Adelson and other Zionist donors, cozying up to figures of Christian nationalism and regressive nostalgia — “Make America Great Again” — brings to mind Herzl’s attempt at collaboration with Russian anti-Semitic Interior Minister von Plehve.

The question is whether the logic and spirit of support for the Jewish state must lead to alliance with other ethnic nationalisms, contradictory to the interests of Jews outside of Israel.

About Abba Solomon

Abba A. Solomon is the author of “The Speech, and Its Context: Jacob Blaustein's Speech ‘The Meaning of Palestine Partition to American Jews.’” His website is abbasolomon.com

Other posts by .


Posted In:

4 Responses

  1. Citizen
    November 22, 2017, 12:52 pm

    “The question is whether the logic and spirit of support for the Jewish state must lead to alliance with other ethnic nationalisms, contradictory to the interests of Jews outside of Israel.”

    Yes, the rest of us, for example goy US taxpayers, are just chopped liver. That’s 98% of American population.

  2. Elizabeth Block
    November 23, 2017, 12:43 pm

    “Guests at the ZOA dinner included former White House figure Sebastian Gorka.”
    Zionists had a neo-Nazi as a guest at their meeting. Do you need to know anything else?

  3. yonah fredman
    November 25, 2017, 10:00 am

    Unity. United we stand. Divided we fall. I write those phrases with irony. We ask questions and when we do so, truth and clarity are higher priorities than unity.
    I would pick three points in time: 1881, then 1945, then today. The mass migration of Jews from the east to the west created or reflected a deep seated turmoil. And indeed the events in Europe from 1914- 1945 vindicated whatever instinct said, Run! to think in bold strokes of self emancipation or territorialism was natural for the times included an emphasis on nation and on will. The times also included white Europeans colonizing lands on the globe. They also included socialism. The totalitarianism that accompanied the dictatorship of a small party claiming to speak for the proletariat was pretty ugly. Yet capitalism wreaking havoc with mother earth can be quite ugly as well.
    We sit 72 years after the war, so our perspective is different. Bibi Netanyahu and Bernard avishai are not twins, they see the world differently and bibi is in power in israel. Probably bibi dismisses avishai as if he were judith butler.

    Adelson and bibi and Shmuel boteach, rubbing elbows with trump and bannon, of course: gag me with a spoon.
    Eli Valley is a talented cartoonist. But he is not yet the voice of reason. Polemicist at this point.

    Alienation from Israel is encouraged by bibi’s style. Those of us with close relatives there or having spent time there have a different perspective.

    Ari Ben canaan was a myth. Baruch marzel is a nightmare. Bibi is a very unpleasant reality.

Leave a Reply