From the category archives:

Lincoln

‘Put this in your Lincoln kick and smoke it’

by Philip Weiss on March 29, 2009 · 2 comments

Neocon Ira Stoll, writing in the Daily News, claims Lincoln for Israel. He says that Hamas has perpetrated the equivalent of slavery and the only way to fight slavery is to destroy it. He, and Cynthia Ozick too, is upset about a new Jimmy Carter book saying that the Civil War could have been averted, and that Lincoln became deluded by messianic ideas when there were better ways to end slavery than war.

My friend Jack Ross seizes on this and writes, "Put this in your Lincoln kick and smoke it."

Beyond the obvious, two points come to mind:

1) Has it really completely slipped my mind to point out in this whole discussion what Lincoln is for the neocons and especially the Straussians, that is, an example to be invoked for any and all atrocities to be committed in a war fought for progress?

2) What, ultimately, is the difference between Lincoln's mythical "Union" and Herzl's mythical "Jewish people"?
[read the full article…]

{ Comments on this entry are closed }

One of my themes is that the Israel lobby has too much power in American life because both parties are behind it. I compare it to the consensus for slavery that existed in the 1850s between Whigs and Dems before Abraham Lincoln broke it up. Today we need a wedge coalition that it going to separate the progressive human-rights Democrats from the colonialist Democrats and the isolationist human-rights Republicans from the Pentagon Republicans and build a coalition that respects human rights in Palestine. I don't know where Sam Haselby, a historian and junior fellow at Harvard, stands on My Issue, but he clearly understands the way that the two-party system defeats insurgent causes in the name of bipartisanship. From the Boston Globe:

After the War of Independence, one partisan faction of revolutionaries pressured the rest to adopt the Bill of Rights. Throughout the first half of the 19th century, slavery enjoyed the protection of bipartisan consensus; only the feverish partisan rigidity of the abolitionists kept the subject in the national discussion. Abraham Lincoln won the presidency as the nominee of a party that was created to break the bipartisan consensus that had, time and again, tried to push the incendiary problem of slavery off the national agenda.
[read the full article…]

{ Comments on this entry are closed }

Freeman ouster is signal, Obama won’t put pressure on Israel

by Philip Weiss10 March 2009

Andrew Sullivan, as demoralized as we are here, says the MSM didn’t cover Freeman and this means that the Israel lobby has won and there will be no change in policy in I/P under shrewd timid Obama. “The fact that…

50 comments

Ellison, Edwards & Baird offer a vision of the post-Israel-lobby Congress

by Philip Weiss5 March 2009

I only have one foot on the ground (that’s the definition of this blog, Rabbi Hillel meets the luftmensch and goes for a ride) but I can’t think of a more hopeful piece to read tonight than rbguy’s wonderful reporting…

28 comments

Abunimah does the numbers: Palestinian majority next year

by Philip Weiss27 February 2009

Yesterday I posted John Mearsheimer’s belief that Palestinians outnumber Jews in historical Palestine right now. Well, here is Ali Abunimah’s estimate from last year, that Jews are 5.15 million and Palestinians 5 million, and both are under 50 percent of…

12 comments

CBS exec’s comments on Palestinian self-government have long American pedigree

by Philip Weiss27 February 2009

Jeff Ballabon, lately appointed a CBS vice president for communications, writing a few months ago: Palestinians simply are not interested in or ready for the creation of a state. Stephen Douglas, the Democratic senator, speaking in Jonesboro, Illinois, in September…

2 comments

The Nation: ‘a thunderous, coordinated assault is underway’ against Chas Freeman

by Philip Weiss26 February 2009

By Robert Dreyfuss. Good reporting. My big new theme, I’m working on this one. In 1857-60, Abraham Lincoln, then an outsider radical and disappointed office-seeker who believed one thing– that slavery was evil– built the Republican Party and broke the…

46 comments

I think Edward Rothstein of the ‘Times’ is a Zionist, and Roger Cohen of the ‘Times’ isn’t, and let’s talk about it

by Philip Weiss24 February 2009

There is a piece in yesterday’s Times that perfectly demonstrates why I believe that it is Essential that the Jewish family divide at last, openly, over Israel. Here it is, by Edward Rothstein. It is all about an exhibit at…

16 comments

Moyers criticizes Israel. And lo, Moyers’s 40-year-old dirty laundry appears

by Philip Weiss23 February 2009

Bill Moyers has the temerity to attack Israel for killing 400 children in Gaza and suddenly he’s being attacked all over for hunting up gay people in the White House 40 years ago. The timing is just too– perfect. Wall…

14 comments

Lincoln put dedication to a great cause above personal ambition

by Philip Weiss22 February 2009

(FYI: This is a post about the Israel lobby and our public life.) Lincoln wrote the following brilliant lines in 1858, at the time of the Lincoln-Douglas debates. This scholar here believes it to be a fragment of a speech….

1 comment

Lincoln on Hamas

by Philip Weiss21 February 2009

Lincoln’s a guide because in 1854 he revived his political career over a moral question, slavery, and transformed the country. At a time when the mainstream political parties were accommodating slavery, Lincoln declared that slavery was evil and he wanted…

19 comments

The man from the planet Mambo

by Philip Weiss21 February 2009

I fear that I’m losing my ability to socialize. I’ve never been a very good socializer, but now in my 50s I’ve become more impatient in social situations, and as the conversation wanders here and there superficially, my mind disappears…

18 comments

Abraham Lincoln, anti-Zionist

by Philip Weiss18 February 2009

In 1855, when Lincoln was helping to form the Republican Party out of the remnants of the Whig Party around a simple moral question, the extension of slavery, a lifelong friend asked him if he was a Know-Nothing, a member…

17 comments

Lincoln would have accepted the idea of a shadowy, powerful Israel lobby

by Philip Weiss16 February 2009

It’s widely agreed that the “House Divided” speech that Lincoln gave in June 1858, accepting the Republican nomination for the Senate and warning that the spread of slavery must be stopped or the whole nation would be taken over by…

22 comments