In his new book on the one-state solution Hussein Ibish says that too many people in my camp hate Israel and want it to go poof. I think he has a point, there’s a lot of anger. That said, Israel has displayed such monstrousness toward the Palestinians, and our own country has issued not a murmur of protest over these acts, and it is hardly surprising that some become enraged. What are we to make of this case of a baby with a heart condition at the Gaza border, prevented from leaving for treatment for two weeks? What monsters would do this to another people? And I say it is Zionist ideology that did this, Zionism as it has worked out over 120 years, with help from European nationalists.The Christian Science Monitor says the case got a lot of coverage, ultimately freeing the child. Why wasn’t it on the front page of the New York Times?
The case of 9-month-old Mutasem Billah Abu-Mastfa, a Gazan baby diagnosed with a severe heart condition, illustrates well the delay and confusion Palestinian families with urgent health issues are facing – and the powerlessness of human rights groups to help. Due to a deterioration of his condition, his doctors in Gaza referred him for treatment at Sheba Hospital at Tel Hashomer, Israel.
His family submitted an application to take him there on Aug. 28, and the hospital was expecting them on Sept. 13. But the family never got a response from the Israeli authorities and missed the appointment they didn’t know they had. The case was taken on by PHR Israel, which has been successful in the past in expediting the handling of urgent medical cases.
"We couldn’t do a thing, since COGAT has stopped answering our phone calls and stopped cooperating with us," says Ran Yaron, director of PHR-Israel’s Occupied Territories department.
"The lower-level officers were told not to pick up the phone, and on the rare cases that they do, they tell us, ‘We don’t work with you. If you need answers or to check the status of a case, go ask the Palestinian Authority.’"
However, he points out, only the Israeli military and COGAT, which is a division of Israel’s Defense Ministry, has the ability to decide on an individual case.
The attitude of the military toward human rights groups has changed significantly since the war in Gaza, Mr. Yaron notes, and in particular this summer since the group Breaking the Silence released a series of controversial anonymous soldier testimonies that suggested shocking behavior in Gaza, which army officials have declared unreliable because they cannot be verified…
The increased media attention over baby Mutasem in the past week, when the human rights groups lodged an official complaint against the new policy and launched a campaign to reverse the decision to shut them out, was likely what helped him get out of Gaza on Thursday.
As his father was crossing through the Erez checkpoint at midday, he told a Monitor reporter of a long ordeal from the day his son was born.
"Today I am here at Erez, and the life of the son I’m holding is in the hands of the Israeli army, which can help him survive or let him die," said Mohammed Abu-Mastfa, from the Khan Younis area of Gaza. After the family waited for weeks for an answer, he explained, they were told by the Palestinian Ministry of Civil Affairs that their permit was refused. No reason was given. "We’ve spent a lot of time just watching him suffering," he said.
Maj. Guy Inbar, the spokesman for COGAT, says that the human rights groups have blown the issue out of proportion
