Rabbis want to criticize Israel but fear donors (and ‘NYT’ buries the news)

Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr

Today’s New York Times has a big and important piece on the divide inside the Jewish community over Gaza and Israel. The article is actually a puzzle: the real news about what’s happening inside the Jewish community is strewn in among anecdotes. You have to piece it together for yourself.

Under the headline “Talk in Synagogue of Israel and Gaza Goes From Debate to Wrath to Rage,” reporter Laurie Goodstein begins by saying that leftwing and rightwing rabbis are hesitant to bring Gaza up lest they divide their congregations. The rightwing rabbi says, “It used to be that Israel was always the uniting factor in the Jewish world.”

Goodstein makes it sound like a one-hand, on-the-other hand story. Here’s her nut graph:

Israel’s occupation of Arab lands won in battle and its standoff with the Palestinians have become so divisive that many rabbis say it is impossible to have a civil conversation about Israel in their synagogues. Debate among Jews about Israel is nothing new, but some say the friction is now fire. Rabbis said in interviews that it may be too hot to touch, and many are anguishing over what to say about Israel in their sermons during the High Holy Days, which begin Wednesday evening.

But get to the fourth paragraph or so and the real meaning of the story emerges. Young Jews are alienated from Israel. They don’t want to hear a word of support! And who is holding the line? Large donors.

Particularly in the large cohort of rabbis who consider themselves liberals and believers in a “two-state solution,” some said they are now hesitant to speak much about Israel at all. If they defend Israel, they risk alienating younger Jews who, rabbis say they have observed, are more detached from the Jewish state and organized Judaism. If they say anything critical of Israel, they risk angering the older, more conservative members who often are the larger donors and active volunteers.

And guess what: it’s not even-steven inside the Jewish community. The liberals are more afraid than the rightwingers to speak out.

one-third of 552 rabbis who responded to a questionnaire put out last year by the Jewish Council for Public Affairs said they were reluctant to express their true views on Israel. (Most who responded were not Orthodox.) The “doves” were far more likely to say they were fearful of speaking their minds than the “hawks.”

Rabbi Jill Jacobs, executive director of T’ruah: The Rabbinical Call for Human Rights, a liberal group with 1,800 member rabbis, said: “Rabbis are just really scared because they get slammed by their right-wing congregants, who are often the ones with the purse strings. They are not necessarily the numerical majority, but they are the loudest.”

THAT is the story. Congrats to Rabbi Jill Jacobs. She shows real courage. Why isn’t Goodstein giving us that story from the start? She should have written:

Rabbis who are critical of Israel’s action in Gaza are afraid to say so in their shuls because they are afraid of angering donors– even though younger members of their flock agree with them.

Late in the Times article, we learn that some of these rabbis even support BDS, boycott, divestment and sanctions. That’s a story. And by the way, all that happened to the rightwing rabbi at the start of the article was he got a letter from a member who was quitting. That’s a bit different from a donor’s call. Just ask Rev. Bruce Shipman. A member quitting and a donor withholding funds — that’s false equivalence.

There is today a revolution taking place inside American Jewish life. Gaza has destroyed many young Jews’ belief in the Jewish state and undermined liberal Zionists’ belief that they can reconcile the two strands of their ideology. The New York Times continues to put its head in the sand.

P.S. JCPA, which reports that doves are afraid to speak out, is a Zionist organization (link). It’s probably undercounting the shift.


Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

I couldn’t read past the first paragraph, in which Goodstein dutifully reports on Rabbi Sharon Kleinbaum conflating “young Israeli soldiers — as well as Palestinian children” in a liturgy.

That’s just wrong. Furthermore, I can’t be bothered to explain how obviously wrong it is. If it isn’t clear to you, retire from whatever sort of public life you have and never post anything online.

>> “For many Jews, Israel is their Judaism, or at least a big part of it.”

Why waste time worshipping an intangible god when you can worship – and even live in! – your very own “Jewish State”!

How sad that “for many Jews”, idolatry is a big part of their faith.

Rabbi Rosen said in an interview: “For many Jews, Israel is their Judaism, or at least a big part of it. So when someone challenges the centrality of Israel in a public way, it’s very painful and very difficult, especially when that person is their rabbi.” Israel is the religion to many Jews who’ve never stepped foot in a synagogue. I’ve seen the exuberant defense of Israel, from many whom don’t even know where the… Read more »

we need english speakers at mossad, please apply here : ———- Careers ​​Given the nature of the Mossad, the acceptance tests are complex and may take some time. The amount of time is subject to how suitable your personal details and your skills are for the position for which you are applying. Candidacy in English may be submitted without marking a specific position. Please note that the questionnaire may take some time to fill out.… Read more »

“who are often the ones with the purse strings. They are not necessarily the numerical majority, but they are the loudest.”

Money YELLS! This is what Bernie Sanders is openly saying about money in politics (on the subject of BIG-FOSSIL-FUEL preventing action on Climate Change).

Read 4 letters to New Yorker (9/22/2014, p.12) on same topic, 2 on AIPAC as an instance of big-money: pay-wwall’d: http://meter.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/09/22/letters-readers-2