Media Analysis

‘NYT’ story on Seth Klarman abandoning GOP leaves out his prominent role in Israel lobby

Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr

Bari Weiss had a big scoop in the New York Times: billionaire investor Seth Klarman is so worried about Trump he’s given up on his traditional favorite, the Republican Party. “Mr. Klarman is now giving almost exclusively to Democrats — and donating far more money than he ever has,” Weiss reports, then quotes him: “We need to turn the House and Senate as a check on Donald Trump and his runaway presidency.”

Trump’s character flaws and “ignorance of history and flawed judgment” are dangerous, Klarman says. “[D]emocratic norms… are being eroded… [Trump] demonizes immigrants and suggests that Muslims, Hispanics and blacks are second-class citizens.”

Weiss identifies Klarman as “hawkish, socially liberal, fiscally conservative.” His and his wife’s family foundation focuses on “pro-democracy initiatives, including supporting organizations that protect journalists, combat bigotry and defend L.G.B.T. rights.”

That’s not the whole story. Israel is never mentioned in the article, but Israel is clearly at the heart of Klarman’s giving. Klarman started a newspaper in Israel, the Times of Israel, and has given to a host of neoconservative Israel lobby organizations, including Trump’s favorite thinktank, the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, the Israel Project, Middle East Forum, WINEP and the David Project, which tried to block construction of mosques in Klarman’s city, Boston.

Klarman is plainly ideological. He also funds CAMERA, a rightwing media outfit that puts out regular critiques of the New York Times. Klarman gave more than $1.5 million to CAMERA through that foundation that works to “protect journalists.”

Haaretz is frank about the Israel angle:

Leslie Wexner [another Republican Party defector] and Seth Klarman have both contributed millions of dollars and are known as supporters of Israel

Shalom Lipner, an Israeli political operative now with Brookings, says the Israel angle may be determinative:

The subtext here is that both Wexner and Klarman have stellar records of support for transformative Israeli and Jewish communal initiatives. That they would break with the GOP over Trump speaks volumes about how they perceive his impact on both Israel and the Jewish community.

What Lipner is saying is that Trump is threatening the pro-Israel consensus in American politics by so politicizing Israel support. This is something that many smart pro-Israel political leaders have emphasized. Chuck Schumer told AIPAC, don’t let Israel become a partisan issue. “If Israel becomes the domain of one party or another, Israel will lose.” Neocon Adam Milstein says so from the right, and Jeremy Ben-Ami of J Street says it from the left:

[I]n Netanyahu’s fervent embrace of the Trump administration, he is “sacrificing” historical broad bipartisan American support for Israel to throw in his lot with Republicans, whose share of the voting population is trending downward.

“It is absolutely not in the state of Israel’s interest for Israel itself to become a partisan political football,” Ben-Ami said.

In Haaretz today, Chemi Shalev warns that Israel will go the way of South Africa on the world stage if it continues to alienate a Democratic Party “depleted of its pro-Israeli stalwarts, increasingly beholden to its liberal, left-wing flank.”

The principle of U.S. bipartisan support, long considered a lynchpin and vital component of Israel’s national security, has fallen prey to an ever-rising tide of self-centered arrogance, imperiousness, resentfulness and total lack of self-awareness.

I’m sure Klarman cares a lot about immigrants. But he also cares deeply about Israel, and you’d have to wonder if this is his game– don’t let Israel become a rightwing issue in US politics. Bari Weiss won’t even broach the Israel angle, beyond giving the code word, “hawkish.” Why not?

Because it’s her agenda too. She comes out of pro-Israel activism, starting in college. (Her father is a regular at AIPAC, saluted from the stage this year.) Weiss doesn’t bring up Israel because she’s protective, she doesn’t want to advertise the power of the Israel lobby, doesn’t want to give readers any understanding of how much clout pro-Israel Jews have. The New Yorker did the same thing in its profile of Paul Singer, all but left Israel out. Not wanting to foster anti-Semitic theories about Jewish power is no excuse to lie to readers.

Thanks to Annie Robbins.

17 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Bari Weiss worked for The David Project or StandWithUs or some other lunatic pro-Israel group while she was a college student at Columbia to harass and oust Arab and/or Muslims professors. She is the same type of lunatic Zionist who wants to censor the Palestinian POV on college campuses and thinks all Palestinians are militants – thus, whenever Israel mows the grass in Gaza, its all Hamas grass. I’m puzzled why Annie would think Bari… Read more »

RE: “Klarman started a newspaper in Israel, the Times of Israel, and has given to a host of neoconservative Israel lobby organizations, including Trump’s favorite thinktank, the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, the Israel Project, Middle East Forum, WINEP and the David Project, which tried to block construction of mosques in Klarman’s city, Boston.” ~ Weiss ■ “Censored film reveals The Israel Project’s secret Facebook campaign” | By Ali Abunimah and Asa Winstanley | The… Read more »

OTopic…On Sunday Joy Reid did a last segment on the Trump/Kushner administration cutting off all aid to Palestinians. Cannot find the clip but she did so. The only MSM host to even whisper. Have noticed that callers into Cspan’s Washington Journal who are both factual about the I/P conflict (and yes there are some anti Jewish calls) have been eliminated by Washington Journal. I know there was a great deal of pressure by CAMERA to… Read more »

Takeaway from Bob Woodward’s book, Fear: Rabid Jewish Zionist Jared Kushner & Helper, Ivanka determine US ForeignPolicy in ME: US blood & treasure devoted to serving #Israel’s expansion & continued hegemony: https://shar.es/a1GIzw via @MiddleEastEye