Harvard students walk out en masse from Israeli consul talk (and liberal Zionists are saddened)

Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr

In yet another sign that Palestinian solidarity activists are getting room inside mainstream institutions, scores of Harvard students walked out on the Israeli consul general yesterday as he began a talk at Harvard Law School on the settlement project. The students were largely silent and held up signs saying, “Settlements are a War Crime.”

Dani Dayan spoke to a largely-empty room and expressed contempt for the demonstrators as being like kindergartners.

More than 100 students “from across Harvard” walked out, according to the Palestine Solidarity Committee at the school. Most of the hall empties in this video of the protest posted by Hamzah Raza, a student at Harvard’s Divinity School.

Dayan is himself a settler and spoke on the “legal strategy of Israeli settlements.” He was sponsored by a program on Jewish and Israeli law at the Law School, and introduced by Noah Feldman, a Harvard law professor and expert on religion, who said that the invitation did not represent an endorsement of Dayan’s views, but a desire to engage his views.

The Palestine Solidarity Committee posted a photograph of the largely empty hall after the walkout. It shared credit for the protest with the “Alliance for Water Justice in Palestine.”

Harvard lecture hall after students walked out on Dani Dayan. Nov. 13, 2019.

Dayan thanked Harvard for hosting him at its “most prestigious institution.” But the Palestine Solidarity Committee statement reports that he was disdainful:

Smiling at the sight of the protesters silently leaving the room, Dayan remarked: “I remember a time doing something similar in my kindergarten.” He later tweeted (translated): “On my way back to NYC I’m thinking why are these people so happy with themselves? A bunch of losers trembling in fear of the disciplinary committees of their school.”

That statement characterized the protest as part of a trend:

This event is part of a growing momentum on Harvard’s campus for justice in Palestine. “We do not intend on sitting out on complicity in oppression,” a student organizer remarked. “Not at Harvard, not anywhere else.”

The Palestine Solidarity Committee also tweeted, “We cannot tolerate his extremist views.”

Israeli human rights attorney Michael Sfard was pleased by the demonstration.

Liberal Zionist Richard Goldwasser seconded the idea that the protest reflects a trend– and Israel better get with it. He endorsed the walkout but said he was saddened.

I support protesting Dayan. At the same time, this saddens me. It’s only going to grow. Israel needs to change course. Now.

Debra Shushan of Peace Now endorsed the protest but echoed Goldwasser’s view. “I feel the same way. If I copied a few lines from your tweet (“This saddens me. It’s only going to grow. Israel needs to change course. Now.”) I could use it as commentary to about half the things I share on Twitter.”

The Palestine Solidarity statement was not saddened:

Dayan is a vocal advocate for the illegal expansion of Israeli settlements into Palestinian territory. In a 2012 op-ed in the New York Times, he wrote that the international community should abandon its vain attempts at the two-state solution and accept the Israeli presence in the West Bank as “an irreversible fact.” Israeli settlements are blatant violations of international law, and the Israeli settler movement is a violent project of settler-colonialism in occupied Palestine.

“I’m disappointed that the Harvard Law School would let this kind of propaganda for a colonial project for accumulation by dispossession be framed as “legal.” This is not only complicit but simply dishonest,” a student organizer remarked. “Let us be clear, there is a consensus among the international community that Israeli settlements are illegal under international law and a violation of the fourth Geneva Convention,” they added.

Thanks to Scott Roth, Terry Weber, and James North. 

Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Hello Harvard students! I applaud your protest of Dani Dayan but I can see that some of you still believe a two state solution is possible – you might want to read Ian Lustick’s “Paradigm Lost: From Two State Solution To One State Reality”, you’ll finish it during lunch! Let me quote from page 121: “There is today one state, the State of Israel, between the Mediterranean Sea and the Jordan River. It is an… Read more »

This saddens you. THIS is what saddens you.? As usual, make it about you.
THIS is what SADDENS me –

I began writing and publishing (in The Village Voice, Grand Street, and other publications) about Israel and its occupation of what was then in the “West” called the West Bank, in 1979. At the time, no one except Noam Chomsky, Christopher Hitchens, and one or two Israeli-Jewish dissidents were writing about Israel’s settler colonialism. Gush Emunim (“Bloc of the Faithful”) had just begun throwing up settlements. The mayor of Halhul, Muhammad Milhem, took me to… Read more »

Mabruk!! Major kudos to those Harvard students who had the courage and integrity to do the right thing and stand with the Palestinians. Zionists are scared to death of you because you are the future and your numbers are rapidly increasing.

The illegal Jewish settlements in the occupied West Bank (including East Jerusalem) have proved catastrophic for the Christian communities of those occupied territories. How strange it is, that so many fervent Christians in the US ignore these brazen illegal settlement activities by Israel.