Opinion

Dreams crushed by trauma

What do you tell a ten-year-old who who has seen carnage around her, when you are also traumatized yourself?
Mondoweiss' Gaza Diaries series shares firsthand accounts of Palestinians who lived through the 11-day Israeli attack on Gaza in May 2021, and are dealing with its aftermath.

Editor’s Note: The article is part of our series Gaza Diaries which shares firsthand accounts of Palestinians who lived through the 11-day Israeli attack on Gaza in May 2021, and are now dealing with its aftermath. You can read the entire series here.

Tiny hands, a slow movement, and a glass of water. A small person in a white lab coat passes an insulin shot to a diabetic old man. Next, she gives him some pills and a plastic cup filled with water.

This small doctor is my niece Shaam, then 4 years old. Her favorite hobby at that time was using her toy medical kit to pretend to fix her sick grandfather. She wanted him to recover fast. 

As a distinguished girl in the family, my brother always encourages her to be a doctor. He bought her only doctor’s equipment. She was eager to fulfill her dream, even her favorite color was white, the color of the doctor’s coat. She is different from other girls of her generation. At playtime, she emphatically chose her plastic stethoscope over a doll. She was lively and optimistic. Her passion for helping people drove her to run around our house in the southern city of Rafah in the Gaza Strip, creating a combination of real and make-believe treatments.

At a family gathering last May everyone was looking forward to seeing her in her white coat. For that reason, I was surprised when I heard her words, “Please auntie, try to convince my father that I don’t want to be a doctor. I don’t think that I can help all of these people.”

This happened immediately after news broke of an escalation between Israel and Gaza that killed 260 Palestinians in 11-days of fighting. We were sitting stiffly in front of the television in our living room, our eyes steadily watching the breaking news. I live with my mum and dad. But during the war, we all gathered in the same place as we were afraid to be apart. Like many of our neighbors, we preferred to stay in one house. This way, we either live together or die together.

How should I tell Shaam that she is not the only one who feels this way? Watching graphic content on the news that week, I could barely handle the horrible scenes. If an adult struggles, how can I expect a child to cope? She’s only ten. 

I thought that maybe after the war ended, and if we survived, she would change her mind and once again be inspired to become a doctor. But one week ago, I heard her mother arguing with my brother, “I can’t let you choose the future career of my daughter. She is a child, she is in trauma,” my sister-in-law declared. “I can’t allow you to force her to be a doctor.” 

She was right. Witnessing traumatic events has changed all of our aspirations. 

About five days into the escalation we were hoping to hear something about an armistice agreement when suddenly the presenter interrupted with breaking news: 17 people in the Kuluk family were killed in Israeli airstrikes on two four-story buildings on al-Wehda Street, killing a total of 30 people. The buildings collapsed from the blasts, leaving two members of the Kuluk family, mother and son, Sanaa and Mohammed, under the rubble until rescue workers pulled them out the next morning. 

Basma Ismail Kurd. (Photo: courtesy of the author)

I used to go to al-Wehda Street for dinner at a favorite Thai restaurant or shopping with my friends after lectures. The street is close to my university. I was an English major and graduated in 2013, although I never had a full-time job as Gaza’s unemployment rate is one of the highest in the world. I am a freelance translator and writer. 

All of these events reminded me of the first of four escalations over the past 13 years. In the winter of 2008 my brother Mohammad— may God have mercy upon his soul—was shot by an Israeli soldier. He was 19 when he died. I was 17. We were really close. He was passionate about becoming an engineer, to help construct homes that were destroyed by Israeli forces. 

And what really breaks my heart is that before his death, only two days before he left us forever, we were talking about our dreams and future careers. He told me that he would build me a house when I get married. Actually, he said, “I am going to build you a princess castle.” He was still a freshman in college. I laughed and I said Amen to all of his aspirations.

Alas, he and his dreams vanished once his death was announced in the news. That’s how we found out. My mother’s cried her heart out. I felt that my soul would leave my body just like how he left me alone. He was my soul mate.

A few days before his death, our neighbors, the Ghanam family, were killed in an airstrike. Six people died in the bombing, one lived. It happened just before dawn. I woke up to the sound of screaming, crying and black smoke filling our house. I could barely see anything as it was dark out and the impact cut our power. For a moment I thought that I was the one under rubble and that I had lost my family. 

As soon as I figured out what happened, I darted to the street and hid near the al-Huda Mosque.

After the sunrise, I explored the situation. In the debris pile that once was their house, I saw all my neighbors’ mangled body parts. Pieces of them were stuck on the walls. Ambulances weren’t able to reach the house, but I suppose it was too late anyway.  

What shocked me more is that when I heard my brother Mohammed shouting and seeking help. “I heard someone moaning in pain. Leave the dead and let us save the living,” he called to me. One of the Ghanam sons was still alive. Husam was 15 years old.  

He was protected by their front door, which fell over his frame, shielding him from the rest of the collapsed house. 

Stories like this are why some of the families in Gaza think that they are safer downstairs so they all sleep in first-floor living rooms during wars. While my brother was helping the boy, he fainted because dirty smoke filled his lungs upon entering the house.

Only one person survived and will lament the loss of his family forever.

My niece and I survived the latest escalation, but I don’t want her dreams to be crushed the way mine were. So many children will never have the same opportunities as us. From wars in 2008-2009, 2012, 2014, and  2021, more than 1,000 children have been killed. 

One can only imagine how all these victims could have built a better future. How many more generations will be deprived of life? At 30 years old, I feel my dreams have been snatched from me. But Shaam, she will carry on what I failed to complete. I will continue to support her and help guide her to achieve her goals. 

4 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

“What do you tell a ten-year-old who who has seen carnage around her, when you are also traumatized yourself?” asks the author. Well, the answer is provided right here by commenters on Mondoweiss!

“Zionism existed a long, long time before Arabs in the Levant found themselves disconnected from the newly created states create by Sykes/Pikot.”

Just tell her that the Palestinian problems are due to their refusal to accept the Sykes/Picot agreement, and furthermore the Jewish old-testament Yahweh has condemned them to collective punishment in perpetuity. Hey, kid, not everyone deserves to have their own state and vote for the people who govern them, get used to it.

1 of 2
Naftali Bennett once led Effort to insert Israeli Propaganda into Wikipedia, now He’s Trying to Shape US Foreign Policy (juancole.com)
“Naftali Bennett once led Effort to insert Israeli Propaganda into Wikipedia, now He’s Trying to Influence US Foreign Policy” by Asa Winstanley, Informed Comment, August 29/21
EXCERPTS:
“Online Palestinian outlet Quds News Network resurfaced a video clip this week from over a decade ago featuring current Israeli Prime Minister Naftali Bennett.
“The video shows Bennett helping to lead a training session teaching Israelis how to insert themselves into Wikipedia (the free online encyclopedia that unknown persons can edit), and push the Israeli government line. [See videos in the article.]
“’The goal of the day is to teach people how to edit in Wikipedia, which is the number one source of information today, in the world,’ he explained.
“’As a way of example: if someone searches the Gaza flotilla, we want to be there. We want to be the guys who influence what is written there, how it’s written, and to ensure that it’s balanced and Zionist in nature.’
“The concept of something being both ‘balanced and Zionist in nature’ is an interesting one. Or rather, it is a total contradiction in terms – much like the idea of a ‘Jewish and democratic’ state.
“If the Zionist perspective was so obviously the correct and ‘balanced’ one, then why does it need a small army of state-backed foreign operatives deceptively inserting itself into online debates?
“The flotillas to Gaza, of course, were a series of non-violent popular resistance activities that activists from around the world held around that time.
“They were attempts to break the brutal siege on the Gaza Strip, which Israel has enforced since 2007. Activists met with some degree of success – before the Mavi Marmara massacre in 2010.
“That year, not long before Bennett spoke in the video above, the largest flotilla to date was hijacked by Israeli troops in international waters. This resulted in the deaths of ten Turkish activists; nine were immediately murdered, some ‘execution-style’ according to witnesses, with the tenth dying of his wounds some years later.” (cont’d)

2 of 2
“Israel was unapologetic, insisting on its supposed right to ‘defend’ itself from the unarmed solidarity activists and their symbolic cargos of siege-busting aid.
“But as a result, Israel suffered in the court of world opinion. A wave of boycotts followed, with several high-profile music acts declaring that they would never play in the country. The Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions Movement (BDS) got a huge boost.
“No wonder Bennett and his minions decided that something must be done about the worldwide battle for the narrative that Israel was losing to the Palestinians – by subverting Wikipedia.
“In the decade since, Israel’s standing in the court of world opinion has only declined.
“Israel has degraded itself, time and time again, by repeated massacres of Palestinians all over Palestine – especially in the Gaza Strip – and by the slow grind of occupation and expulsion of Palestinians from their homes in the West Bank, to be replaced by Israeli settlers.
“Israel has almost given up trying to convince anyone else it is in the right. On a certain level, the country’s leaders know that battle was lost a long time ago. Instead, they resort to lobbying efforts aimed at banning, outlawing, or at least chilling and suppressing, criticisms of Israel and its official racist ideology: Zionism.
“Last year, former Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu boasted of having ‘promoted laws in most US states’ that ban or otherwise inhibit the BDS Movement’s activities.
“Of course, Netanyahu did not mention that these laws are all blatantly unconstitutional and are likely to be swept away. Every time these laws are challenged in higher courts, they are struck down as violations of the First Amendment to the US Constitution: the right to free speech.”
“Bennett is a hard-right, violent, anti-Palestinian racist. In other words, he is like every other Israeli leader before him. But Israel seems to have perfected the knack of every single succeeding prime minister being more racist and right-wing than the last.
“Soon after embarking on his political career, Bennett infamously declared: ‘I have killed lots of Arabs in my life – and there is no problem with that.’”